The other hypothesis is that horses disappeared by the early Pleistocene.
Conventional thought is that as Euro traders and explorers made their way around NA, they brought horses. A new train of thought is that all horses are of European derivation, but were used by earlier generations of indigenous traders who got their horses from the earliest Europeans.
Nuanced for sure.
Native Americans spread the animals across the West before Europeans arrived in the region, archaeological evidence and Indigenous knowledge show
www.smithsonianmag.com
Hello,
Yes, it would be nice to have multiple specimens and DNA samples of several breeds of indigenous horses whose genetic lines have not been mixed with horse breeds who originated on other continents... but there are very, very few of these indigenous horses left.
Sadly, despite the fact that the BLM is aware of the fact that the wild horses on our range lands are not only immune but sterilize the soil where the prions exist that cause "Mad Cow Disease" in cattle, "Chronic Wasting Disease"in deer and elk, "Scrapie" in sheep and Creutzfeldt - Jakob disease in humans; these beautiful animals continue to be rounded up by the BLM, sold and sent over the border to Canada where they are slaughtered for meat or sold to the Chinese as "live cargo" and slaughtered in China.
(EnviroNews Colorado) -- A Colorado State University scientist is investigating the role wild horses may play in slowing the spread of Chronic Wasting Disease
www.environews.tv
Wild horses' immunity to prions - the toxins causing Chronic Wasting Disease - gives them a unique place on the range lands.
horsetalk.co.nz
Excerpt:
"It is quite important to note that among large North American herbivores, wild horses (an American native species:
click here) are
uniquely immune to prions, arguably so through some evolutionary process, which we do not yet understand.
And by abating grasses and brush (each horse consuming 30lbs. of dry grass and brush daily) one of the suspected vectors, wild horses can meaningfully reduce environmental prions affecting other grazing animals, including cervids. This is important because the rate of infection for this prion disease (CWD) is believe to be
dose-related. Such grazing by wild horses also has the added benefit of reducing the fuels (grass and brush) for catastrophic wildfires as I discuss
in this article.
As we consider all of the foregoing, in light of the BLM's notion of removing even more wild horses from public lands to increase and extend grazing areas for cattle and sheep into known grazing areas where cervids are present, such a move is clearly a "
bad idea" according to Dr. Zabel."
Also, here is a very interesting PDF of a Dissertation entitled, "The Relationship Between The Indigenous Peoples Of The Americas And The Horse : Deconstructing A Eurocentric Myth" by Yvette Running Horse Collins, PH.D., that is quite informative:
Excerpt from Chapter 1 bottom of page 2:
"When the European explorers arrived in the Americas, they brought with them their belief that all that was "civilized" originated from their homeland and their culture. At the time of the 1500s, 1600s, and 1700s, one of the marks of "civilization" included one's possession of the horse and one's mastery of horsemanship skills."
...and Excerpt from Chapter 1 middle of page 4:
"Dakota/Lakota Elders as well as many other Indian nations . contend that according to their oral history, the North American horse survived the Ice Age, and that they had developed a horse culture long before the arrival of Europeans, and, furthermore, that these same distinct ponys (sic) continued to thrive on the prairies until the latter part of the XIXth(19th) century, when the U.S. government ordered them rounded up and destroyed to prevent Indians from leaving the newly-created reservations. 13"
I also remember reading in National Geographic way back in the late 1990's or early 2000's ? that they had discovered a geothermally heated valley in northern, frozen, Alaska where animals (including prehistoric horses) that they had formerly believed to be extinct still survived and thrived. But after that...I could never find any other information ever published about this discovery again, so I am guessing that they might not wish for curious visitors to pollute that unique ecosystem.
Apparently, the Vikings were trading with our Native American tribes in the Great Lakes region about 1,000 years ago and the Bronze Age in the Mediterranean would never have happened without Michigan copper (modern metallurgical testing). There is a fascinating book about this entitled:
Michigan Copper the Untold Story a History of Discovery by C. Fred Rydholm
There is so much of our commonly accepted history that is inaccurate...it would be wonderful to be able to time-travel and see for ourselves
