Arrest, Search, Seizure, Warrant How do I proceed?

Status
Not open for further replies.

GreenTerror

New Member
I am facing a court martial for 1) Violation of General Order 1 while deployed to Iraq, 2) inappropriate relationship with a subordinate, 3) lying to a commissioned officer. A female asked a member of S6 to take a look at her computer for her because it had a power issue. She did this in his and her off time and at his barracks room (witnessed). This soldier took the computer to their office the next day. He could not fix the problem then let another S6 member try. This S6 member fixed it then searched her computer and copied picture, video and emails documents. They said their OIC had given them permission to search any computer entering the shop. During her trial the OIC flat out denied this. She stood a summary CM and lost. She had presented a motion to dismiss the evidence based on illegal search and seizure, it was denied by the summary CM officer.
Do I have a leg to stand on seeing as how the evidence was obtained from some one else's computer? Would the fruit of the poisonous tree apply for me? If she appeals and wins will that help me? What do I do? I am still waiting to have charges preferred and TDS cannot help until then or until an Art 32 investigation has begun.
 
I learned today that my Brigade Legal Team has not even submitted my case to the Commanding General (General Court Martial Authority) for decision and determination. I was told this was going to a special CM back in the 1st Week of November and still they have not submitted it. How long do they have, is there a time limit?
 
If, through appeal and citing a recent military case which I have found, I can show that and prove through precedence that the initial search of the other party's personal computer was illegal, can that same searched and seized evidence be used against me? I do not believe that the 4th amendment applies here to me but would that same evidence be fuit from the poisonous tree?
 
If, through appeal and citing a recent military case which I have found, I can show that and prove through precedence that the initial search of the other party's personal computer was illegal, can that same searched and seized evidence be used against me? I do not believe that the 4th amendment applies here to me but would that same evidence be fuit from the poisonous tree?

You are talking about a constitutional amendment for CIVILIANS. You are in the Military, military law applies.

No civilian lawyer can give you advice, they don't know the military law/rules that apply to you.

I strongly urge you to find someone in the Military who is better equipped to deal wit this matter.

I don't think any search of any kind is "illegal" in the Military, you became part of the governemnt product when you signed that contract to join. I feel for you, believe me, but you are talking an entirely different ballgame here, and for your own benefit, I urge you to contact someone with military experience in these matters.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top