I'm I responsible for the mold?

Status
Not open for further replies.

joser03

New Member
I searched for a few threads but my case is different. I will try to be as specific as I can.

My brother, sister, and I moved into an apartment in July of 2007. After we moved in, we noticed that the kitchen sink had a leak. Also, there was a foul smell. We contacted the landlord and she sent her handyman. He told us that there was a bad case of mildew. The leak continued and she had to call in a business to fix it. Not only that, the garbage disposal was broken and that had to be replaced as well. The shower in the master bedroom also had a leak. The handyman attempted to fix it but could not. Another business was called in to fix it. The rug in the master bedroom also smelled like a wet dog. A carpet cleaner was called in and they cleaned the rug. The smell remained. The master bedroom window and frame needed to be replaced (6 months later, it was just completed.)

There are other minor details but the main problem is mold.

I do have every email saved to back up my side of the situation.

In September, I sent an email to the landlord that we had discovered mold growing. Not on the walls or floor, but on our clothes and furniture. We also discovered that the carpet in my sister's room was wet in one particular location. I thought it could be a pipe that was leaking. She called some people to check out the problem and they discovered that it was not a leak. She told us that the problem was that we were watering too much. We have a backyard and we do water the grass and plants. Water from outside was seeping under the apartment and causing the carpet to become wet. This room is not next to the outside wall, but two rooms into the house. I thought this was strange. What happens when winter comes and it rains every day? The floor continued to stay wet and we continued to find mold. She told us to turn on the heater more often and to open windows to prevent the mold from growing. We did not turn on the heater (it costs money and it was not cold), but we did open windows and keep the house clean. We continued to find mold on clothes, hats, furniture, picture frames, and even on the mouse for the computer. My girlfriend started feeling sick after spending the night in the apartment and my sister and I developed a bad cough. If this was connected to the mold, I do not know. We told her [landlord] that the house has a lot of moisture. We finally convinced her to call a professional and after a few tests, it was determined that there is a lot of moisture in the air and that it was causing the mold and immediate actions needed to be taken.

The company could not believe that we had been living in this condition for so long. They installed dehumidifiers throughout the house, in every bedroom to dry out the house before construction. We were told that the construction was going to take no more than 4 days. Our landlord tried to put us up in a motel under the freeway but we refused. We all have different work schedules and we all cook. If we are going to be out of our house, we want to at least live in a hotel that is as close to a house as possible. I found such a place. The first two days my brother and sister stayed with my parents. This saved the landlord money. We each had our own room. The hotel costs were put on my credit card.

During the construction, the bedrooms were emptied out (which we were not prepared for) and everything was cleaned. The inner walls were torn down and I assume new insulation was installed (but I am not sure.) The landlord rarely contacted me with the progress of the construction. On a few occasions, I was the one who contacted the manager to get an idea on the progress. Four days turned to six days which turned into a total of nine days of living in a hotel. The landlord was not happy that she had to pay for the now large hotel bill. During the construction, she went on vacation. On our return home, we found that the apartment was not yet complete. The rooms needed to be painted and the house was a mess. All of our items were not back in our room and my brother's room was far from being completed. We were tempted to return to the hotel but we decided that as long as we could sleep on a mattress, we would stay. In one email she sent me, she did not even know the days we were gone. I have had to correct her many times. She also insists that we requested that someone be called in to inspect the house in December when in fact we notified her about the problems in September (I do have the emails.) She eventually paid for the hotel costs and the additional costs to our electric bill. Once again she told us that we need to run the heater and keep the house ventilated (which we do.)

Now nearly two months, we have found mold growing on clothes, backpacks, and furniture. We have been turning the heater on and keep the house ventilated. The company that "fixed" the house made suggestions to the landlord and the steps she needed to make in order to prevent a breakout of mold. One, to replace the windows in two of the bedrooms. She has not done anything since. When the heater is turned on, my brother's and sister's rooms do not stay warm. Heat does come out of the vents but the room does not get warm. We think the heat is escaping through the faulty windows ot through the old walls and stucko. She sent someone to check the heating ducts and they discovered problems. The problems were fixed but still, the rooms remain cold. I believe that there is structural damage and she is refusing to make the repairs and instead telling us to just turn the heater on. There was property damage before and after the construction and she said that she would send $100 (not nearly enough) to cover the damages but it was contingent on signing a release of property claim.

It is obvious that she had her lawyer work on it and from what I understand, she is attempting to remove herself from any further damages that may occur due to another mold infestation. Anything damages would be our fault and our responsibility. I do not think this is fair. If there is indeed structural damage that is causing the mold growth, why should I be held responsible? We keep the house clean. We turn on the heater. We keep the windows open (when it's not cold or raining.) Are we responsible for the mold that grows in the apartment? She is putting our health at risk again. I called the company but they cannot tell me the recommendations they made to her without her authorization.I feel like I do have the right to take her to court. I have kept all the emails and have pictures. Can I and for what exactly? I refuse to sign this paperwork. I really do not know what to do next, especially with mold growing once again.

I'm I reading the Release correctly? She has said that we complain too much, but all of our complaints are of things that should have been taken care of before we moved into the apartment (leaks, broken windows, no screens over windows, broken garbage disposal, etc.)

Any help would be GREATLY appreciated.

Thank you!
___________________________

Below is the paperwork she sent us to sign. Names and addresses have been censored.
___________________________
 
Last edited:
RELEASE OF ALL CLAIMS
The undersigned, --------,--------, and --------- warrants and acknowledges by signing this Release that the claims released herein as described in greater detail below, are those claims against or arising from their tenancy at -----------, CA 94530 from the signing of the lease on July 6, 2007 to the date of the signature of this Release. This Release relates to any property claims, complaints or damages of any kind or nature arising out of or in any way related to the mold damage claim handling and settlement, including any claim related to any and all mold, mold spores, fungus or other spore condition and related remediation repairs, and specifically includes any and all known, unknown or contingent rights that the undersigned has ever had or may thereafter acquire under the contract or otherwise.
SCOPE OF RELEASE

The undersigned acknowledges and warrants that by signing this Release, they intend to and do discharge, abandon, and waive all claims, demands, actions, and causes of action for property damage, loss of claims or prospective economic advantage, diminution in value of tangible property, and all other property loss and/or damage of any kind or nature, anticipated or unanticipated, known or unknown, disclosed or undisclosed to this point, which now exist or may exist in the future, arising out of or in any way related to any loss, loss settlement payment, and any other claim as set forth above, including but not limited to any and all claims pertaining to the settlement of the water and mold or fungus loss damage.
The undersigned further acknowledges and warrants that they intend to and do release, waive, discharge and abandon any claims for damages against the parties released herein for interference with prospective economic advantage, inconvenience, diminution in property value, or any other damages in any other way caused, which might be asserted by the undersigned to have been caused by mold, mold spores, fungus or other spore condition and related remediation.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF DISPUTE
The undersigned acknowledges that this final compromise and settlement of all claims shall never be admissible as evidence of or treated as an admission of liability or of a right to any additional payment for dwelling repairs or mold remediation related to the tenancy at any time in any proceeding or for any purpose.
WAIVER OF CIVIL CODE SECTION 1542
The undersigned further expressly represents and warrants that he has read the provisions of Section 1542 of the Civil Code of the State of California, which section reads, at the time of execution of this Release:
A. A general release does not extend to claims which the creditor does not know or suspect to exist in his/her favor at the time of executing the release, which if known by him/her must have material affected his/her settlement with the debtor.
The undersigned, after being informed of his rights of consultation with an attorney, hereby waives the application of this provision. The undersigned represents and acknowledges that he understands that the significance and consequence of this waiver of Civil Code § 1542 is that even if they have additional damages or eventually suffers additional damages arising out of the circumstances set forth above, that they will not be able to make any claim or recover in a lawsuit for those damages.
The undersigned acknowledges that they intend these consequences even as to claims for damages that may exist as of the date of this release but which they do not know exists, and which, if known, would materially affect their decision to execute this release, regardless of whether the lack of knowledge is the result of ignorance, oversight, neglect, error or any other cause.
PARTIES TO BE RELEASED
The undersigned warrants that they intend to and do, by signing this Release, discharge and release from any claims, demands, actions, and causes of action as set forth above, Hannah ------, Trustee and her employees and subcontractors and the Yoshii Family Living Trust Dated December 4, 1989 and its employees, agents and adjusters.
PARTIES BOUND

The Release shall be binding upon the heirs, executors, administrators and assigns of the undersigned. In consideration the undersigned acknowledges and warrants by their signature on this Release, the receipt of a settlement draft in the sum of one hundred dollars [$100.00], payable to ------, ------, and ------ which is accepted in full compromise and settlement and satisfaction of all claims described herein, in addition to already received payment for their stay in the Extended Stay America, 3650 Mandela Pkwy, Oakland, CA 94608 for a period of time from November 23, 2007 through December 1, 2007 for a total bill of two thousand three hundred and forty-four dollars and sixty-seven cents [$2,344.67], with credit for the eight days of rent while Releasing parties stayed in the hotel and full credit for remainder of December rent, for a cash payment of one thousand two hundred and eight dollars [$1,208.00], as well as twenty dollars [$20.00] for laundry services paid November 23, 2007 in cash, and a payment of one hundred and seven dollars and seventy-seven cents [$107.77] for PG & E services during the time of remediation, and fulfilling of the described conditions are the sole and exclusive consideration for this Release of All Claims.
The undersigned further warrants and represents that no promise nor inducement has been offered, except as herein set forth; the undersigned further warrants that this Release is executed without any reliance upon any statement or representation by the person or parties or entities to be released herein or by any of the representatives, attorneys or investigators, concerning the nature and extent of the damages sustained or the rights of the undersigned or of any other parties.
Releasing parties also agree to abide by all clauses and requirements of the lease agreement signed on July 6, 2007 regarding ----- -------- Avenue, #1 ---------, CA 94530 including the requirement to use ample heat and ventilation, and proper cleaning procedures, to said unit to deter the further growth of any and all mold, mold spores, fungus or other spore condition.
HOLD HARMLESS
The undersigned represents and warrants that they have not heretofore assigned, transferred or purported to have assigned or transferred to any person or entity any liability, claim, action, cause of action, or right herein released, herein discharged, or any portion thereof. In the event any person or entity should assert that it has been assigned or transferred any rights, actions, or causes of action that are the subject of this agreement, the party hereto who actually or purportedly made such transfer or assignment shall defend, indemnify and hold harmless all other parties to this agreement, and their respective successor in interest, from any and all liability, claims, damages, actions, causes of action, including payment of attorney's fees and costs actually incurred, whether or not litigation be commenced, based on, in connection with or arising out of any such assignment or transfer of purported or claimed assignment or transfer.
CAPACITY TO EXECUTE THIS RELEASE

The undersigned represents and warrants that they are of legal age, legally competent to execute this Release, fully understands the Release, and that they accepts full responsibility for this Release after careful consideration of this matter. The undersigned further acknowledges and warrants that they have been informed of their right to consult with their own personal attorney, and warrants that they understand the legal effect of this release and executes this Release freely, voluntarily, and without fraud, duress or undue influence.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF the undersigned does hereby execute this Release of All Claims and settlement agreement this th day of January 2008, at , California.

________________________________


________________________________


________________________________
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top