Insubordination Questions

Status
Not open for further replies.

sneakers80

New Member
Greetings,

I'm not looking to rant, or vie for ones sympathy, nor am I trying to win a popularity contest, I simply would like a little insight into options, or perhaps a work around for what I'm currently facing at my Job.

I'm currently working in as a CSR (Customer Support basically) for an undisclosed organization. We have VERY slim, IF ANY formal guidelines, procedures or documents regarding work place conduct, violations, disciplinary matters or anything else to that affect.

A new Manager has been hired as the Manager of Support and in spite of the best efforts I keep making, I feel as though I'm constantly being beaten down. The few things I do know, based on customer response, and general feedback is A: I'm knowledgeable, confident, and have tremendous phone manner and B: I get the job done, leave customers pleased and do overall an amazing job.

This being said I feel as though in spite of all good actions my Manager has targeted me for whatever personal biases she may have, whether she feel threatened, the need to prove herself or maybe just a superior complex or maybe none of the above and I am a complete douche who is doing his or her job terribly.

As of late what had transpired was simple, I have a voice message box and on it, I left my Cellular Phone Number, they don't pay us for time, and it was my personal line, but honestly I was trying to go above and beyond, my intentions were pure, perhaps misguided since they were not paying for it, but none the less my intent was a positive one. I wanted to stick out (evidently I did).

Now, what happened was my supervisor had sent me out an e-mail, not a verbal warning, nothing physical, or personal but an e-mail asking me to remove my number.

For whatever reason I read it and it slipped my mind because I was extremely busy, not an excuse but an explanation. So anyways, a week or two go by and I hear nothing until December 12th, another e-mail evidently was sent to my box asking me yet again to remove the Number from my Voicemail. I saw the title of the message something like "Hello" or "Voicebox' or something on those lines, anyways it wasn't in our designated "queue" and we've been extremely busy over the holiday so again it slipped my mind. Now, I figured if this was urgent as opposed to her relying on an e-mail she could physically come and verbalize this to me: "Please remove this" As opposed to an e-mail. That is just my thought. Regardless, today I get pulled into the office with her and the letter basically said:

"You have been asked 2 times to remove your voicemail and have not responded to the emails that were sent to you, or changed your voicemail message. This behavior is considered "in subornation" (yes, there were NUMEROUS typos on this document). Refusal to follow a manager's instructions or respond with an action plan will not be tolerated.

Your behavior has a negative impact on the department as well as "customers". There must be decided improvement in your responsive to email as well as direction. Specfically you must treat your manager and co-workesr with apprpriate cooperation. (I am not making these typos, this is how the letter came out, I kid you not).

Needless to say,

I just wanted to debate, contest or otherwise dispute the following points:

Insubordination to the best of my knowledge simply put would be refusing my bosses requests.. Now I never said to her I would not do it, I mean honestly it slipped my mind, maybe it's not the greatest of explanations but it's valid and truthful.

I just disagree in the context she is using "insubordination" I don't believe anything I did falls under that category. If it was that important she should have come to me and asked me in person and not relied on e-mail. What were to happen for instance if I had never gotten the e-mail, or mail servers were down, or my computer exploded (ridiculous for effect). Anyways, that being said I just want other ideas on this.

A: What can I do?

B: Is there anyway I can challenge this to yield constructive results, such as an improved work environment.

My goal isn't to leave my job, it's to make it so it's manageable but if my manager wants me GONE, which is fairly evident by this elaborate conception of dribble. Is it even worth it?

Anyways,

Feedback, opinions or anything would be nice.

Have a great Holiday!
 
I figured as much :)

But as a general question, I find it highly ironic that an employer would punish an employee for having good intentions. Labeling things or finding excuses to discipline employees where probable cause doesn't exist is slanderous.

Anyways, it's Christmas, Merry Christmas right? :)

General feedback or comments from a human perspective are always nice as well, I mean can we not classify this generally as opposed to region or country specific?

So for instance, if this were in the states what kind of rules would apply in these situations are they warranted in calling something insubordinate even if it is not. Furthermore, is there no legal precedence to concocting elaborate schemes, reasons or excuses with malicious intent (or even blatantly lying), I.E. writing someone up only to clear up the path in the future making it easier to fire/dismiss or otherwise remove said employee from employment. I mean I know in some cases falsifying reports is illegal, however technically I guess nothing was really falsified, everything was just contorted into nonsense she could use against me.

Blah!
 
IMHO, it's petty and childish. But here, there are no laws against managers being so. In a few states here, the law provides that employees may rebut a negative review in writing and have such writing placed in their personnnel file, though. And "insubordination" is in the eye of the beholder; new managers sometimes want to come in and throw their weight around--not that unusual. Legally, "insubordination" relative to unemployment benefits would have to be serious and pervasive to result in denial of benefits. Other than that, all I can say is keep your head down. Eventually, she'll get tired of playing repressive dictator; or HR will start reviewing her write-ups and counsel her on how to properly manage employees. Or, she'll run employees off, and the company will do exit interviews and find out why.

Ho, Ho, Ho! :D
 
Do as she says so you keep your job. If it were me I would do it but in a round about way so I would not get fired.....let her know some how that you know your job and maybe she doesnt. You know that kinda cockey but acceptable attitude. She probably has some sort of complex where she wants to let everyone know she is the "boss" Good luck.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top