meal breaks?

Status
Not open for further replies.

KarinP

New Member
my employer tells me that I'll be subject to disciplinary action because I do not punch out and then back in for a 30 minute meal break. I am a nurse and work the 3pm to 11pm shift. I am the only nurse on the unit I work on and cannot leave the floor because there is no other licensed nurse to cover for me. They've told me I must punch out for 30 minutes according to law, if I do punch out for 30 minutes, I still have to stay at the nurse's desk to answer the phone, speak with family members, take care of pharmacy deliveries, etc. I've told the employer and payroll person that I'm still working and that it is too busy for me to actually leave the floor and take a real break. Can they do this? I refuse to leave my patients unattended.
 
Last edited:
my employer tells me that I'll be subject to disciplinary action because I do not punch out and then back in for a 30 minute meal break. I am a nurse and work the 3pm to 11pm shift. I am the only nurse on the unit I work on and cannot leave the floor because there is no other licensed nurse to cover for me. They've told me I must punch out for 30 minutes according to law, if I do punch out for 30 minutes, I still have to stay at the nurse's desk to answer the phone, speak with family members, take care of pharmacy deliveries, etc. I've told the employer and payroll person that I'm still working and that it is too busy for me to actually leave the floor and take a real break. Can they do this? I refuse to leave my patients unattended.

Here is MA law on the subject. There are a few exceptions, and those follow. I suggest you print this information out, and discuss it with your management or HR. I suppose a compromise would be to have someone keep an eye on things while you're enjoying your break. If an emergency were to break out, the caretaker could page, text, or telephone you.

In fact, you don't have to be that far away from your station. If I were you, I'd find a way to compromise.

Your employer has no choice in the matter, and neither do you. So, discuss it, and come to a happy medium.

Meal Breaks

Massachusetts law states that employees must receive a 30-minute break after six hours of working. An employee must be free to leave the workplace during the break. An employee can voluntarily give up the meal break, but must be paid for all hours worked. Compensation for the 30-minute meal break must be paid if the employee has voluntarily agreed to waive his or her meal break by (1) working through his or her meal break, or (2) remaining on the premises at the request of the employer during the meal break. The break period may be unpaid. Certain exemptions from this requirement can be found in M.G.L. c. 149, s. 101.

Section 101. The preceding section shall not apply to iron works, glass works, paper mills, letterpress establishments, print works, bleaching works, or dyeing works; and the attorney general, if it is proved to his satisfaction that in any other factories or workshops or mechanical establishments it is necessary, by reason of the continuous nature of the processes or of special circumstances affecting such establishments, including collective bargaining agreements to exempt them from the preceding section and that such exemption can be made without injury to the persons affected thereby, may grant such exemption as, in his discretion, seems necessary.


Sent from my iPad3 using Tapatalk HD
 
my employer tells me that I'll be subject to disciplinary action because I do not punch out and then back in for a 30 minute meal break. I am a nurse and work the 3pm to 11pm shift. I am the only nurse on the unit I work on and cannot leave the floor because there is no other licensed nurse to cover for me. They've told me I must punch out for 30 minutes according to law, if I do punch out for 30 minutes, I still have to stay at the nurse's desk to answer the phone, speak with family members, take care of pharmacy deliveries, etc. I've told the employer and payroll person that I'm still working and that it is too busy for me to actually leave the floor and take a real break. Can they do this? I refuse to leave my patients unattended.


that's just it....I have to stay on the unit, I can hide in the back room, but how relaxing is that? and people will still come in to see me about questions, etc. There are two unlicensed CNA's on the floor, but they can't sign for the pharmacy deliveries, answer doctor's questions, speak to family members, etc....visitors get upset because there's no nurse available, complaints come in, and the administrator gets upset because of the complaints and if I don't do any work on my break, then I have to stay late to finish the paperwork and there's overtime.
 
So what is your suggestion? Are you suggesting that your employer should knowingly violate the law?
 
I have my nursing license to think of. and I have the patients to think of. I take little breaks to go to the bathroom, etc.
 
I have my nursing license to think of. and I have the patients to think of. I take little breaks to go to the bathroom, etc.

Using your logic, those bathroom breaks put your nursing credential in jeopardy. They don't, by the way, you're human.

You should discuss this with HR, your administrator, and Nursing Supervisor or manager.

But, you can also seek new employment. Your RN nursing credential Is your ticket out of this morass.


Sent from my iPad3 using Tapatalk
 
We have here a matter of competing laws. There is no question that it is legal for your employer to force you to take a meal break. MA law requires that you take a meal break. It is not your choice; it is not your employer's choice. It is the law. Period.

The law provides for one opt - you and your employer can agree that you will give up that meal break and you be paid for the time. However, it should be noted that the law allows for that; nothing in the law is going to force your employer to agree to that. If the employer does not want to pay for that time, nothing in either Federal or MA law will force him to allow you to work time he does not want you to work.

I am not an expert in your industry laws, but I am understanding you to say that there is a law stating that a licensed nurse must be present at all times. If this is so, then your ONLY option is to ask your employer how they want that handled, because you do not have the option of refusing to take a meal break unless the employer agrees to allow it and agrees to pay you for that time. If this is going to run into overtime, they may not want to, and again THE LAW WILL NOT FORCE THEM TO.

Here's hoping they will be reasonable.

Good luck.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top