mightymoose
Moderator
No one asked this girl for i.d., she came from 2 cities over to have sex with a man and presumably to "hang out". From what the defendants are saying her i.d. was a topic that came up in conversation, concerning further partying [i.e. clubbing].
Whether or not she showed ID does not matter. Her age is what makes it illegal. Whether it is a statutory rape or some other kind of sexual misconduct depends on the state statutes, but relying on the argument or her telling lies, not providing ID, or intending to have sex with someone anyway does not change the circumstances. If she is too young to consent then her intention don't matter, and it is the responsibility of the adults to know what they are dealing with.